Review: Whisky Galore (2017)
On 5 February 1941, during gale force winds, the SS Politician ran aground off the Island of Eriskay in the Outer Hebrides. The hold contained 25,000 cases of blended Scotch which the Islanders were determined would not go down with the ship. It was rescued and hidden from the authorities. This incident formed the basis for the 1947 novel Whisky Galore by Compton McKenzie and the classic 1949 Ealing film of the same name. Now 70 years after the novel, Whisky Galore has been remade, and while it may not be the same vintage as the original, it’s still a fine brew.
Despite being spared from the ravages of World War II the isle of Todday has suffered a horrible misfortune, due to severe rationing it has just run out of whisky, news that causes at least one resident to keel over dead. However, as if a gift from heaven the SS Cabinet Minister runs up on the rocks off the island with a cargo full of the precious fluid. The Islanders, led by postmaster Macroon (Gregor Fisher 1984) intend on savaging its cargo, but this being a Sunday, the local minister (James Cosmo, MONOCHROME, SKYLINES) expects them all to be in church and respecting the Sabbath.
There’s also the matter of the Home Guard, led by the bumbling and full of himself Captain Wagget (Eddie Izzard ACROSS THE UNIVERSE, DAY OF THE TRIFFIDS) who’s determined to recover the plundered spirits and romantic subplots involving Macroons daughters Catriona (Ellie Kendrick GAME OF THRONES) and Peggy (Naomi Battrick BRIMSTONE) and you have the makings of a delightfully old-school comedy.
And that’s really what Whisky Galore is, and old-fashioned, family-friendly comedy. When I read the producers saying it wasn’t so much a remake as a modern re-interpretation I was worried that it would be turned into a raunchy booze-soaked comedy. And while there’s nothing wrong with raunchy booze-soaked comedies, it wouldn’t have been right for this project. Thankfully they have captured the spirit of the original quite nicely.
With a nice collection of odd characters and increasingly silly and convoluted cat and mouse games to keep the whisky hidden along with the romantic subplots, Whisky Galore is perfect for a lazy afternoon’s entertainment.
Appropriately, the film is being released by Arrow Films, best known for its restoration and reissues of classic films.